Home page
SPONSOR AD

Support our Vendors!  |  Advertise Here

Topic: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan

in Forum: C3 Cooling and Heating Systems


Already a Member?
Login
Not yet a Member?
Register for Free!

Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (1/26)
 11/22/12 5:28pm
tinbender
Former Member

Send Private Message

edgwood, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1975 convertible,with the hard top and power streering.it a 350 L48 with auto trans. the color is light blue.


Joined: 11/1/2007
Posts: 736

Still working on my overheating problem,I am going to change both the upper and lower hoses and the water pump. My reasoning is I don't know how old these parts are. I have a flex fan that is still in the box and was wondering if it would matter if I took off the clutch fan ...car dose not  have A/C. So would it matter if I changed the fan?
                      Thanks Rick
Our Sponsors help support C3VR
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (2/26)
 11/22/12 6:06pm
Gunslinger
Former Member

Send Private Message

Frederick, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1969 convertible L71 427/435 4-speed black interior


Joined: 9/8/2003
Posts: 3398

Your overheating problem could possibly be caused by a bad fan clutch...it does happen.  One way to check it is to let the engine run up to normal temperature than stop the engine.  If the fan keeps on spinning the fan clutch is bad.  A good fan clutch should stop nearly as quick as the engine.  

Outside of that, I would keep the fan clutch...it's there for a reason.  With a flex fan you might gain a lot of fan noise.  If the flex fan is made of fiberglass, it can develop stress cracks with time and a blade can break off while spinning and fly into something under the hood.  That doesn't happen often but it's been known to happen.

What are the conditions your engine overheats?  Does it do so only at highway speeds, low speed or both?  Is it actually overheating?  You could have a bad sending unit, gauge or thermostat.  Has the cooling system been pressure tested (along with the radiator cap)?  Are the seals around the radiator in place?  Is the air deflector under the front end there?

Just replacing parts may not find the problem.
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (3/26)
 11/22/12 6:35pm
rod7515Lifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Send Private Message

Red Lion, PA - USA

Vette(s):
1974 White 350 Corvette, TH400 Automatic 1972 Tangerine /Go Mango Convertible 383 Stroker, 2004r Automatic


Joined: 10/27/2006
Posts: 1182

Im in Agreement with not using a flex fan. Ive seen the damage they can do when they let go. I would hate to see someone near it at that time. The one I know of that came apart was an aluminum blade that went thru the shroud and dented the hood. Probably come thru one of our fiberglass hoods.
Remember that the car used to cool so you know if all your components are working its a proven system. You havent done any engine work that would have changed anything? When does the engine overheat. If you want to try another fan clutch I have the one off the 72 I am not using. You can give it a shot. Also does your shroud have any breaks in it? Have you checked the actual temp? Does it push coolant out the over flow while running or when shut off? Did you try changing the thermostat? Does the lower hose collaspe while driving. Im not that far from you if you need a hand sometime.
Rodney


______________

Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (4/26)
 11/22/12 8:23pm
F4GaryGold Member
Gold Member
Send Private Message

Grapevine, TX - USA

Vette(s):
1972 LT-1 convertible with factory air.


Joined: 8/26/2006
Posts: 1409

What kind of shape is the radiator in?

______________

   

Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (5/26)
 11/22/12 10:10pm
KDADDY79
Former Member

Send Private Message

Dutchess County, NY - USA

Vette(s):
White '79 Corvette. It's a driver.


Joined: 8/27/2007
Posts: 2484

I replaced the fan clutch on my '79 a few years ago. Solved the problem and it was an easy job.
I'd shy away from the flex fans, too.
Kevin
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (6/26)
 11/22/12 10:27pm
tinbender
Former Member

Send Private Message

edgwood, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1975 convertible,with the hard top and power streering.it a 350 L48 with auto trans. the color is light blue.


Joined: 11/1/2007
Posts: 736

 I changed the clutch on the fan two years ago,when I take the car out it overheats as soon as it starts to get warm.(don't take long).The hose going into the the thermostat housing gets really hot and if you grab it you can feel the pressure on it,the strange thing is the radiator cap is cold and has no pressure on it.I've been told by a couple of people the the bottom hose has clasped or that the impeller on the water pump is bypassing. So not knowing when these three things were last worked on I decided to change them.As for the radiator I will look it over while I have everything apart.Oh I did change the thermostat and it didn't help.  As for the flex fan from your experiences I think I will stay with the factory fan setup.As soon as I find a way to move the car to a place to work on it I will change the parts and post the results.....Unhappyright now I'm a little gun shy on working on anything in front of my house.
                Thanks Rick
 
    P.S Thanks for the offer Rod I'll keep you in mine.


|UPDATED|11/22/2012 7:27:32 PM (AZT)|/UPDATED|
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (7/26)
 11/23/12 11:37am
danascar
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Germansville, PA - USA

Vette(s):
1974 Coupe 358ci 4 speed Black w/Medium Saddle interior w/79 custom leather seats. . 1999 C5 Convertible, 6 speed, Atomic orange, Oak interior.


Joined: 1/28/2010
Posts: 858

Try removing the T-stat and run it....you could have gotten a bad new one. Hose going into T-stat hot and under pressure sounds like T-stat not opening

______________
   

DanT

Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (8/26)
 11/23/12 9:12pm
Andy61
Former Member

Send Private Message

, - Australia

Vette(s):
1969 convertible blown 350 4 speed manual


Joined: 11/20/2012
Posts: 16

There may be another issue namely with your engine, check the water and make sure there is no oil in it and also check the oil on the dipstick, if the oil on the dipstick is creamy coloured, you may have done a head gasket. Advanced timing will also make the engine run at a higher temp, I had the same problem with overheating and found the distributor lock bolt had loosened and the timing advanced on it own enough to cause overheating.

 
Just a thought.


______________

  

Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (9/26)
 11/23/12 9:23pm
tinbender
Former Member

Send Private Message

edgwood, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1975 convertible,with the hard top and power streering.it a 350 L48 with auto trans. the color is light blue.


Joined: 11/1/2007
Posts: 736

 Well I got the top hose replaced,water pump replaced then the problem Shocked ....I couldn't find the right bottom hose. I found plenty of hoses ,but none had the spring so I called corvette america and order one. Should be here Tuesday. I want to give Rich (Yostusota) a thank you for the phone help today. Well when I'm done everything except the radiator has been changed in the cooling system so I will see if problem solved.
                                    Rick
 
           Only bad thing is I have to leave the car on the street till fixed
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (10/26)
 11/23/12 9:31pm
tinbender
Former Member

Send Private Message

edgwood, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1975 convertible,with the hard top and power streering.it a 350 L48 with auto trans. the color is light blue.


Joined: 11/1/2007
Posts: 736

 I think gunslinger hit the nail on the head the spring on the bottom hose was shot,But instead of just doing it I decided to replace everything (no telling how old the hoses were and water pump was original.No water in the oil (thank goodness)
                                     Rick


|UPDATED|11/23/2012 6:31:41 PM (AZT)|/UPDATED|
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (11/26)
 11/24/12 2:31pm
JohnRR
Former Member

Send Private Message

Joined: 2/22/2011
Posts: 110

You guys talk about Flex Fans letting go.  The previous owner of my '73 BB had the stock clutch fan fly apart.  It took out part of the shroud and blew a large hole in the hood!  It took him 3 days on the road to get parts and get it fixed.  I never liked the sound of the fan on this engine. At higher RPM's all I can hear is the fan.  It makes me want to shift to get rid of the crappy noise.  I'm going with DeWitts dual electric fans and hopefully, they'll only come on in traffic.

John


______________
1973 BB 4-Speed Coupe Project Car
2009 Z06 Mostly Stock
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (12/26)
 11/24/12 2:37pm
Gunslinger
Former Member

Send Private Message

Frederick, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1969 convertible L71 427/435 4-speed black interior


Joined: 9/8/2003
Posts: 3398

If your fan is as loud as you say then someone may have replaced the original fan clutch with an incorrect one.  That's not uncommon when they're replaced.  

I will say that if you're not concerned about originality electric fans are the way to go.  
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (13/26)
 11/24/12 11:58pm
yostusota
Former Member

Send Private Message

York, PA - USA

Vette(s):
1969 daytona conv. all original 350 350 380 4 sp w/air..and hard top


Joined: 5/18/2010
Posts: 1518

Flush out that radiator while you got it apart....I mean alot!!! I flush mine 2 times every year....it looks like stalactites in there!! Or I hate to say remove it and have it cleaned.....but...flush kits are cheap and clean out the goop really good...LMK!!!!

______________

My first parade at Carlisle 2010
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (14/26)
 11/25/12 12:32am
JohnRR
Former Member

Send Private Message

Joined: 2/22/2011
Posts: 110

If you're flushing it twice a year and getting out lots of junk, then it sounds like there is something else wrong with the cooling system.  

John


______________
1973 BB 4-Speed Coupe Project Car
2009 Z06 Mostly Stock
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (15/26)
 11/25/12 4:13am
lukesvetteLifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Send Private Message

HOWELL, NJ - USA

Vette(s):
1979, Targa Blue (72 Color), Pace Car rear spoiler, L88 hood, Dark blue factory interior, 525HP 406, HD 700R4, 370 gears,Steeroids, composite rear spring, TT IIs wrapped in T/A Radials.


Joined: 5/18/2004
Posts: 6812

Rick, I had the same symptoms and was finally cured by a bottom hose with the spring. What was happening was the bottom hose without the spring would collapse while driving. The spring cured it - everything else on the car was new so no other gremlins.

Hope the bottom hose solves the mystery for you.Smile

Paul
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (16/26)
 11/25/12 8:49am
yostusota
Former Member

Send Private Message

York, PA - USA

Vette(s):
1969 daytona conv. all original 350 350 380 4 sp w/air..and hard top


Joined: 5/18/2010
Posts: 1518

John...the problem with my car is that the radiator is original and had little to no maintenance in its life..I may remove it this winter and get it cleaned out...hope Rick doesn't have to do that and the new hose with the spring works out.

______________

My first parade at Carlisle 2010
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (17/26)
 11/27/12 8:56pm
tinbender
Former Member

Send Private Message

edgwood, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1975 convertible,with the hard top and power streering.it a 350 L48 with auto trans. the color is light blue.


Joined: 11/1/2007
Posts: 736

Got my new hose today from corvette America. If all go right I'll be putting it on Thursday afternoon( got a interview in the morning) ....so I will post after I try it out will let you all know if successful. Rick

|UPDATED|11/27/2012 5:56:50 PM (AZT)|/UPDATED|
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (18/26)
 11/27/12 11:09pm
NorskyLifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Moderator
Send Private Message

Burke, VT - USA

Vette(s):
SOLD - "The Toy" - '70 Convertible
SOLD - "The Beast" - '90 ZR-1 (#682)
SOLD - "Betty" - '28 Ford Model A Tudor
Still have - "BLKBRRD" - '78 Pontiac Trans Am


Joined: 1/23/2002
Posts: 7191

Hope the new lower does the trick.  Running abit without the t-stat in place would also let you see it the radiator is indeed cooling enough.  If there is a build up of rust and/or scale in the radiator that could impede the cooling.  A fellow on the Model A club I've joined has recommended running pure vinegar in the cooling system to dissolve the crub.  He claims it cleaned everything out clean as a whistle.  I know the cooling systems between a Model A and a C3 Corvette are quite abit different but they're very similar in function.
 
Also make sure the radiator support seals are in place.  Any air slipping through the gaps between the radiator support and the radiator is air that isn't helping to cool.


______________

Jim Olson 

"The Toys"...!!!  Save the Wave!

Where I've been in a Corvette...!!!

Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (19/26)
 11/28/12 12:12am
kstyerLifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Moderator
Send Private Message

CUYAHOGA FALLS, OH - USA

Vette(s):
1975 C3 Red, T-Tops, Black Interior. All I need is time and money! Getting there!


Joined: 12/2/2003
Posts: 6424

Just two comments.
 
Don't forget to check the actual flow.  I have seen water pumps that seem okay but have impleller blades rotted or rusted to the point they either are not there or have come loose from the shaft.    It just won't pump the coolant.   Uncommon, but not rare.
 
Removing the thermostat completely will allow a quick check, but when driven can acutally CAUSE and overheat problem.   The stat acts like a restrictor to flow, slowing it down at high engine speed.   IF the coolant flows too fast it can travel through the radiator quicker than it can be cooled, resulting in still too hot coolant going back into the engine, and not cooling, but overheating instead.
 
While this usually does not happen at low to medium engine RPM,  many driving conditions can cause this to happen.   Often racers will remove the t-stat but install a restrictor in it's place.  This is nothing but a large washer with a hole in it to control the coolant flow.
 
Of course removing the t-stat and starting the car will allow you to see the volicity of the coolant flow through the radiator, if you can see in the tank.  Some of our designs may prevent getting a clear view, but most will allow it.
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (20/26)
 11/30/12 9:00am
knotacare
Former Member

Send Private Message

Newark, DE - USA

Vette(s):
1968 Conv, 454HO,500HP-600TQ, TKO-600,3:70 HD rear,hotrod air, custom paint & suspension,1973 Ruby Red,T-top, 383 Stroker, TK)-500,frame off restro, 1967 Dodge Coronet, 340 stroker to 406, Dana 60


Joined: 7/26/2004
Posts: 463

Good flex fans work fine & will tolerate 10K RPM. I've used them on various cars for many yrs with no problems. If your car is overheating & you have a correctly placed fan, clutch,flex or electric you have other issues. Making sure all air goes through the radiator is a real problem & will cause overheating at highway speeds on C-3's. If your bottom hose is being sucked in your radiator is probably clogged. Water wetter will really help bring the temp down 10-20 degrees & running a 25% antifreeze mixture will help too. water dissipates heat much better than antifreeze, but you need some antifreeze to control corrosion. I personally use flex fans on 2 high performance engines & they keep the engine right at 175-180 degrees in all weather. I also have one with electric  fans that also work  fine. Flex fan can be noisy , but if you exhaust is noisy you'll never notice it.  So I think it really comes down to a personal choice. Flex fans can be adjusted in & out to really get the proper air flow which is critical to coolling efficiency.
Alan


______________

                                               

Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (21/26)
 11/30/12 6:31pm
JohnA71GreenBB
Former Member

Send Private Message

Chadds Ford, PA - USA

Vette(s):
1971 BB, 4spd, Convertible, Brands Hatch Green 1990 L98, Auto, Convertible, Polo Green Met


Joined: 8/21/2012
Posts: 16

I found this on Willcox Corvette and thought it might help.

http://willcoxcorvette.com/instructions/johns_cooling_article.pdf


______________

Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (22/26)
 11/30/12 10:10pm
tinbender
Former Member

Send Private Message

edgwood, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1975 convertible,with the hard top and power streering.it a 350 L48 with auto trans. the color is light blue.


Joined: 11/1/2007
Posts: 736

Well I got everything changed,man what a pain in the *#*.I also did a couple of small fixes. Well ran out of time so tomorrow is the big day to see of I fixed the overheating problem. If not then the only thing left is the radiator. Rick
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (23/26)
 12/1/12 5:48pm
sfindlan
Former Member

Send Private Message

Badin Lake, NC - USA

Vette(s):
1979 Red L-48 Corvette with Doeskin interior, 3-speed automatic, 3.55 rear; 1986 L-98 Coupe, 4+3 Manual - Satin Black and Purple (SCCA TT/Hillclimb Car); 1993 White LT-1 Coupe, Black Interior, 6-speed


Joined: 4/21/2004
Posts: 101

I am another one in the no flex fans club - I race in SCCA events and they are not permitted for a darn good reason. And I have had them let go, with one in particular creating a nice hole in the hood of a classic 1969 Ford LTD.  A fan with a clutch will be as effective in cooling, if not more so, and is much safer. Check the clutch!  Other items to check that caused some heat problems with my C3:
1. Shroud in good shape and properly installed
2. seals between hood and radiator are critical to prevent air from just spilling over the top of the radiator
3. air dam/spoiler in place.
4. if all else fails, get a nice Spal electric fan to supplement the cooling
 
Just my humble opinion....good luck. I had to work on mine to get it cool during NC summers.


______________
C3: 1979 Corvette Coupe, Auto, L-48, Red/Doeskin (my wife's fave);
C4s: 1986 C4 coupe (SCCA road race car), satin black, 4+3, Z51 package, L-98;  & 1993 C4 coupe, white, 6-speed, LT-1.
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (24/26)
 12/1/12 11:43pm
Jaws79Lifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Send Private Message

Sykesville, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1979 Corvette Coupe Corvette Light Blue Midnight Blue interior Mirrored Glass T-tops


Joined: 4/27/2008
Posts: 4238

Rick, if you do have to replace the radiator get the direct fit aluminum one. I got mine from Corvette America but MAM and Corvette Central sells the same one. Made an amazing difference in my car! Good luck and hope it works out!
 
Barry
 
Thumbs Up


______________
"Down on the Boardwalk...

(Click image to see a larger version}
 
Lifetime Member #181
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (25/26)
 12/2/12 11:11am
tinbender
Former Member

Send Private Message

edgwood, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1975 convertible,with the hard top and power streering.it a 350 L48 with auto trans. the color is light blue.


Joined: 11/1/2007
Posts: 736

Well I let the car  running and got it up to temp....then drove it for a little the temp got to just below the 200 line and stayed there.(I have a 195 thermostat) So hopefully this solves my overheating problem.
                                Rick
Re: Flex Fan or no Flex Fan (26/26)
 12/2/12 3:03pm
Jaws79Lifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Send Private Message

Sykesville, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1979 Corvette Coupe Corvette Light Blue Midnight Blue interior Mirrored Glass T-tops


Joined: 4/27/2008
Posts: 4238

Yeah! I love when aproblem gets solved! Great to hear, Rick!
 
Barry
 
Clap


______________
"Down on the Boardwalk...

(Click image to see a larger version}
 
Lifetime Member #181
Our Sponsors help support C3VR