I've heard good and bad about Keisler over time (the Mopar guys hate Keisler with a passion). My only dealings with them was positive though I ended up not buying from them.
About six years ago I talked to them at Corvettes at Carlisle about one of their 5-speeds I was interested in for my '69. The rep was great, they had a show special going on and I put a deposit down on a unit, with a six week delivery time.
As it turns out, before it could be delivered I unexpectedly ended in the hospital for nearly a week, and not knowing how bad the medical bills would be I contacted Keisler to cancel the order. They could not have been better...they cancelled the order and refunded my non-refundable deposit which I wasn't expecting.
While I never received the product, I can say my dealing with Keisler was very positive. I have no reason to say otherwise.