Home page
SPONSOR AD

Support our Vendors!  |  Advertise Here

Topic: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine

in Forum: C3 Engines


Already a Member?
Login
Not yet a Member?
Register for Free!

Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (1/23)
 11/9/12 1:30am
Vetto1974
Former Member

Send Private Message

Hayward, CA - USA

Vette(s):
I have 1974 Corvette, with white exterior and silver interior. It has 350.


Joined: 10/9/2012
Posts: 30

Hi I have been contemplating in regards to my engine. I came across with this company in California, west coast engines, www.westcoastengines.com. The remanufactured crate engines. I am looking at 350 ci, 325 hp. The price, $2,499 plus shipping and core of $300. They are using vortec heads. It seems a good price. Is worth buying remanufactured engine? Or, it is better to rebuild my engine? Do you think by rebuilding my engine, will I get to 325 hp? Need help to decide.

|UPDATED|11/8/2012 10:30:31 PM (AZT)|/UPDATED|


______________
Desert StormDesert Shield Veteran Semper Fi
Our Sponsors help support C3VR
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (2/23)
 11/9/12 9:35am
VikingVette
Former Member

Send Private Message

Greer, SC - USA

Vette(s):
1978 Black with Viking mural painted under hood AM/FM/CB radio, T-top and a 2013 Cyber Gray Grand Sport Coupe, 2LT for my daily driver


Joined: 3/13/2012
Posts: 264

I can only tell you what I decided.  I have a '78 and when I bought it, I could tell the compression just was not what it probably was when it was new.  A lot of people are very concerned about "numbers matching".  I have a plain, black '78 and it will NEVER be a high dollar car, except to ME!!!!  I went the route of a new crate motor.  I went with ZZ4 and have issues with the valve seals leaking (I am still chasing that issue).  I had thought about having the original engine rebuilt, because the L-82 was a 4 bolt main.  The new crate engine was just under $4,000.  Until this valve seal issue came to light, I had been happy with my decision and if I had to make that decision agian, I would go the same route....a new crate motor, but do more research this time.  I am probably one of the dumbest ones on C3VR, so I am sure that others will speak up and give you better opinions on which way to go.
 
Peace out 


______________
Warning: The surgeon general has declared that it is NOT unhealthy to smoke your competition AND I just discovered that my corvette is a hybred.  It burns gas and rubber! 
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (3/23)
 11/9/12 10:22am
knotacare
Former Member

Send Private Message

Newark, DE - USA

Vette(s):
1968 Conv, 454HO,500HP-600TQ, TKO-600,3:70 HD rear,hotrod air, custom paint & suspension,1973 Ruby Red,T-top, 383 Stroker, TK)-500,frame off restro, 1967 Dodge Coronet, 340 stroker to 406, Dana 60


Joined: 7/26/2004
Posts: 463

It's very easy to get 300-350 hp out of a stock 350. I personally go with the engine I already have first as long as it's OK. Find a good machine shop & talk to them then make your decision. 
It's alot easier to upgrade your original engine than install a different engine. 
AlanBeer


______________

                                               

Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (4/23)
 11/9/12 1:08pm
Gunslinger
Former Member

Send Private Message

Frederick, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1969 convertible L71 427/435 4-speed black interior


Joined: 9/8/2003
Posts: 3398

What I did in one of my cars (not a Vette) was install a GM Performance 350HO/330hp engine.  It already has Vortec heads and no core to exchange...I sold the old engine which helps mitigate some of the costs.

Of course the crate engine came with no intake but there's many, many options for that.  In my case, I went for Edelbrock EFI, but induction options are no problems...from basic to wild.

You really need to decide exactly what you want out of your engine, actual use and performance wise...even more than the actual horsepower rating.  Base your choices on that and you'll be much happier than simply buying an engine baed on ratings alone.
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (5/23)
 11/9/12 2:53pm
eldredjamesLifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Send Private Message

Temple City, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1969 Daytona Yellow. 350 / Automatic.


Joined: 10/3/2010
Posts: 365

My Vette came with a ZZ4 already installed.  It is rated at 355 HP and 405 Torque.  I don't know if the headers on it add more HP but it has enough power for me.  I haven't had any issues with the engine, just the installation:  Tach doesn't work and the gas tank was rusted out.

http://www.chevroletperformance.com/EngineShowcase/index.jsp?engId=ZZ4350&engine=ZZ4%20350&sku=12499712&engCat=sb
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (6/23)
 11/9/12 6:53pm
Vetto1974
Former Member

Send Private Message

Hayward, CA - USA

Vette(s):
I have 1974 Corvette, with white exterior and silver interior. It has 350.


Joined: 10/9/2012
Posts: 30

Hi, Basically, I just want to drive my car on weekend. I don't want it to be superjet. I want it to be reliable and yet, the power is there when needed. I don't want to go crazy on the engine because it might turn out that I need to change my tranny, then the rear end. I am not ready for that yet..lol I would like to thank you for all the suggestions. With that said, I think I will just work on the engine that I have now. I called a shop today and he kind a mentioned that crate engines are good and also some of them are really bad for they are not assembled in US. Some are using par products than others. He also suggest to work on my engine just because it is 1974 and want to maintained matching number. I talked to a shop that will help me rebuild my engine. He is charging $1900 on labor. This does not include any porting of the heads or the block itself. He is thinking of just getting a re-build kit for the lower block, changing the rings, maybe pistons, if needed, crank shaft. We will send out the head to get it ported at around ($300) to a bigger hole and maybe changing the springs. I am thiking of putting the following parts: cam (camshaft), intake (edelbrock performer 2101), carb (holley 750 cfm), lifters, rockers, harmonic balancer, flexplates, and gear drive and headers, simple, like hooker, full lenght or shorty. I asked around in regards to MSD box, coils, and distribrutor..they said it is not needed for the engine is just mildy modified, if it considered modified. So, what do you think of the set up? How about MSD? Let me know. Thank you

|UPDATED|11/9/2012 3:53:19 PM (AZT)|/UPDATED|


______________
Desert StormDesert Shield Veteran Semper Fi
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (7/23)
 11/10/12 11:28am
danascar
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Germansville, PA - USA

Vette(s):
1974 Coupe 358ci 4 speed Black w/Medium Saddle interior w/79 custom leather seats. . 1999 C5 Convertible, 6 speed, Atomic orange, Oak interior.


Joined: 1/28/2010
Posts: 858

Hers's the distributor I went with on my mildly modified motor.....
Works well and has the tach drive and is priced right....good luck.


|UPDATED|11/10/2012 8:28:46 AM (AZT)|/UPDATED|


______________
   

DanT

Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (8/23)
 11/11/12 12:27am
kendo2
Former Member

Send Private Message

Ormond Beach, FL - USA

Vette(s):
77 coupe, yellow, auto, L series, A/C, T top, Grey leather interior. It is about 75% & matching #'s. The miles are 117K & intend on restoring bit by bit to enjoy Cruises & rallies in Florida , & maybe some shows ?


Joined: 7/28/2012
Posts: 19

Have you thought about contacting Summit Racing or JEGS about your engine rebuild. Their prices are good & they have all sorts of engine upgrades. i.e. cams, heads,etc. Go to the internet & Google their web sites, as it may help you decide on certain accessories for your project.
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (9/23)
 11/11/12 5:13am
Vetto1974
Former Member

Send Private Message

Hayward, CA - USA

Vette(s):
I have 1974 Corvette, with white exterior and silver interior. It has 350.


Joined: 10/9/2012
Posts: 30

Hi, thank for your suggestion. Yes I have in contact with summit racing. I talked to their tech a couple of times. In one instance, the guy suggested 650 cfm for my carb and the other time they suggested 750 cfm. What should I use? Also, edelbrock or holley?

______________
Desert StormDesert Shield Veteran Semper Fi
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (10/23)
 11/11/12 12:09pm
Gunslinger
Former Member

Send Private Message

Frederick, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1969 convertible L71 427/435 4-speed black interior


Joined: 9/8/2003
Posts: 3398

Unless you have a built-up engine a 600 or 650 cfm carburetor is all you need.  Any normal, not too built up 350 would be hard pressed to use up 600 or 650 cfm anyway and anything bigger can cause a hesitation at take off unless it's highly tuned in and of itself.

As far as brand goes, I like the Edelbrocks as they're easily adjustable, hold their adjustments and are probably a bit better on fuel economy.  If you're looking for pure performance then maybe Holley might be the way to go, but that's still arguable as there's simply so many variables in any particular engine.  

My own feeling that I would go with an Edelbrock EPS intake with an Edelbrock Performer 600 carb or maybe an Edlebrock AVS 650 carb.  The EPS intake is designed strictly for square-bore carbs and has somewhat better horsepower and torque numbers than their Performer 2101 intake.  That choice would likely require a low mount air cleaner though...not a big deal.
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (11/23)
 11/12/12 2:27am
daveo76
Former Member

Send Private Message

Vancouver, WA - USA

Vette(s):
1976 Silver/Firethorn. L48, 4spd. Original 2 bolt, vortec heads, 9.4:1 CR, Speed Pro Cam: 224/224@0.050, 112 LSA, Eagle Steel Crank.


Joined: 8/25/2005
Posts: 857

I had the same debate a couple of years ago with my engine.  I narrowed it down to three choices:

1) crate motor
2) buy an already rebuilt motor from a local engine builder or machine shop (there are always SB chevy's advertised on Craigslist -- do your homework)
3) rebuild my original block

After considerable debate and lots of research I went #3.  Found a local machinist, talked with him at length, checked references, etc.  He did the block and set up a pair of used Vortec heads for me, I did the ass'y.  I'm glad I went the way I did since now I still have my original block (and heads, but they're not installed) and I was able to build my own engine which is a big one for me in the pride department (first time).  But the crate motor option is a good one that is worth considering.  GMPP seems to be the best, but I think there are other good ones out there.  I was considering S&S Engines out of Spokane.  Just do your homework before going that way.  Make sure the warranty is up to snuff. 

FYI - not sure I saved any money by rebuilding my existing block.....still happy though.  


______________

 

1976 Silver/Firethorn.  L48, 4spd.  Original 2 bolt, vortec heads, 9.4:1 CR, Speed Pro Cam: 224/224@0.050, 112 LSA, Eagle Steel Crank.
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (12/23)
 11/12/12 3:08pm
fp_vetter72Lifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Send Private Message

COPPERAS COVE, TX - USA

Vette(s):
1972 corvette stingray convertible 2007 coupe


Joined: 7/6/2002
Posts: 417

I put a 350 crate in mine, 3 year 50,000 mile warrenty for less than  $1500. I purchased the engine from Jegs. The car has the origanal componets on it except intake which is an edelbrock performer great performance and has been very dependible. I still have the origanl motor and will go through it one of these days.

______________

Click for larger view
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (13/23)
 11/12/12 5:22pm
Vetto1974
Former Member

Send Private Message

Hayward, CA - USA

Vette(s):
I have 1974 Corvette, with white exterior and silver interior. It has 350.


Joined: 10/9/2012
Posts: 30

Hi, You bought a long block from Jegs and you used all your external parts, such as, water pump, oil pump, pullies, starter, and so on, except for the intake? And slapped it in on the block?

______________
Desert StormDesert Shield Veteran Semper Fi
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (14/23)
 11/18/12 6:31pm
tonytheroofer
Former Member

Send Private Message

Rochester, NY - USA

Vette(s):
1980 L- 82 fully restored and upgraded.


Joined: 6/12/2012
Posts: 95

You can buy a brand new crate block with heads for 1500 .. I would get a carb to pan 290hp crate from jegs for like 2500 ,, your never gonna beat that deal with starter water pump fuel pump carb .. It really is about the most affordable way to do a engine replacement ,, 

______________
1980 , ZZ430 , 3.92 rear , 700R4 2400 stall NEW EZ EFI 
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (15/23)
 12/6/12 1:36pm
Andy61
Former Member

Send Private Message

, - Australia

Vette(s):
1969 convertible blown 350 4 speed manual


Joined: 11/20/2012
Posts: 16

I am going the build a new one from the start. this way i get exactly what I need and I know what parts have gone into the engine. It is much more expensive and time consuming. I have spent around $6500 not counting my labour.



|UPDATED|12/6/2012 10:36:03 AM (AZT)|/UPDATED|


______________

  

Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (16/23)
 12/6/12 1:54pm
Vetto1974
Former Member

Send Private Message

Hayward, CA - USA

Vette(s):
I have 1974 Corvette, with white exterior and silver interior. It has 350.


Joined: 10/9/2012
Posts: 30

I am still doing a lot of research. Finally down to little details. Question: How can I tell my compression is low and I need to overall my lower block. My plan is now is to have my cylinder heads work on and rebuilt, change the intake, carb, cam, rollers, lifters. But not really doing anything to my lower block. The car runs, but, with 189 or 190 bhp, I know that theres is nothing in it. What do you think?

______________
Desert StormDesert Shield Veteran Semper Fi
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (17/23)
 12/6/12 5:45pm
Andy61
Former Member

Send Private Message

, - Australia

Vette(s):
1969 convertible blown 350 4 speed manual


Joined: 11/20/2012
Posts: 16

A compression test gauge or the more accurate option, a cylinder leak down test, I have found that by only doing the top end  of an engine, you have the potential for bottom end failure.

|UPDATED|12/6/2012 2:45:46 PM (AZT)|/UPDATED|


______________

  

Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (18/23)
 12/12/12 1:41pm
Vetto1974
Former Member

Send Private Message

Hayward, CA - USA

Vette(s):
I have 1974 Corvette, with white exterior and silver interior. It has 350.


Joined: 10/9/2012
Posts: 30

Hi. Is it easy to install the engine yourself after you had it worked on (block and heads)? I am not a handy man so, it might different in my case. I also ask around about vortec heads. They told me because of the clearance issue, vortec heads, and vortec compatible intake will not work. What is your thoughts on this? How much hp is now your engine puts out? What ratios that your block and heads? Thank you

______________
Desert StormDesert Shield Veteran Semper Fi
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (19/23)
 12/14/12 11:03pm
dads2vetteLifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Send Private Message

Ash Fork, AZ - USA

Vette(s):
1981 Red Interior White exterior


Joined: 4/18/2007
Posts: 1053

I had this same thought process a couple of yrs ago. I went with a crate motor because I am keeping the car so It's gonna be worth the same to me (and my daughter) no matter how original it is and by the time I sent the original out for machine work it would have brought the price up considerably.
 
As far as installing it yourself...if it's not an exact match you might wind up running into problems with wiring and vacuum lines.  I ordered a crate motor from Phoenix engines and got a good deal.  Unfortunately, by the time I was in a position to install it I had to move and lost my shop(garage) in the process.  I hired a mechanic to install the motor for me and he screwed it up.  On my next project car, if it needs a new motor, I'll go to a local speed shop and get a motor from them.  Some around here will give a break on installation as well.
 
My suggestion is to go with someone local...go to a car show or cruise night and get some suggestions.  Folks in the hobby are always willing to help.  Even if it costs a little more it's ussually easier dealing with locals.


______________
Dave C..........My mantra: I can not be bought!!      Long and short term leases available.
In the words of Zora Arkus-Duntov "Is your seat belt fastened? Alright, Let's go"


Yeah, I know, Shut up Dave.
Lifetime Member #192


Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (20/23)
 12/15/12 3:53am
daveo76
Former Member

Send Private Message

Vancouver, WA - USA

Vette(s):
1976 Silver/Firethorn. L48, 4spd. Original 2 bolt, vortec heads, 9.4:1 CR, Speed Pro Cam: 224/224@0.050, 112 LSA, Eagle Steel Crank.


Joined: 8/25/2005
Posts: 857

Vetto1974 said:  I also ask around about vortec heads. They told me because of the clearance issue, vortec heads, and vortec compatible intake will not work. What is your thoughts on this? How much hp is now your engine puts out? What ratios that your block and heads? Thank you


Vortec heads fit under the stock hoods, you just have to use the correct manifold and air cleaner.  I used a GM manifold similar to this one except mine is a spread bore (bigger rear bores for the giant secondaries of a Q-jet carb)

http://www.ebay.com/itm/GM-Vortec-Dual-Plane-Intake-Manifold-Chevy-SBC-283-327-350-Fits-Vortec-Heads-/330832827129?hash=item4d072c52f9&item=330832827129&pt=Motors_Car_Truck_Parts_Accessories&vxp=mtr

For the air cleaner, there are a number of options.  I used a 2.5", 12" Dia. K&N.  It's a tight fit under there, but they definitely do fit.  I'd have a big hole in my hood now if they didn't!  As for numbers, I estimate somewhere between 300 - 350 HP, based on comparing my specs for the specs on similar crate motors.  My compression ratio is about 9.4:1.  Have to use premium or at least mid-grade gas.  

There are a number of issues that need to be resolved (even beyond clearance) if you do go with Vortec heads.  You can search on this site for "Vortec" and come up with many of them.  Feel free to PM me if you want more info.  


______________

 

1976 Silver/Firethorn.  L48, 4spd.  Original 2 bolt, vortec heads, 9.4:1 CR, Speed Pro Cam: 224/224@0.050, 112 LSA, Eagle Steel Crank.
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (21/23)
 12/16/12 4:39am
Vetto1974
Former Member

Send Private Message

Hayward, CA - USA

Vette(s):
I have 1974 Corvette, with white exterior and silver interior. It has 350.


Joined: 10/9/2012
Posts: 30

Hi, what do you think of this combo? Summit Racing Part Number:CMB-08-0034 I am not thinking of doing anything to my lower block, do you think thats ok? Do you think with the combo above my lower block will be able to handle it? I will also change my carb and add cam. Another question, do you know some that had use obx side exhaust?

______________
Desert StormDesert Shield Veteran Semper Fi
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (22/23)
 12/16/12 10:38am
tonytheroofer
Former Member

Send Private Message

Rochester, NY - USA

Vette(s):
1980 L- 82 fully restored and upgraded.


Joined: 6/12/2012
Posts: 95

It sounds like you trying to do this as affordable as possible. And there really is no cheaper way to re-do a motor then getting a 1500.00 short block and installing your parts to it (ie) intake carb starter exhaust manifolds. Would a numbers matching car be worth more ? My vote in your case is no and with no disrespect numbers matching includes a lot of investment during a restore and you seam happy (rightly so ) to drive and enjoy the car. 

Look to jegs and get there 260hp motor it will be a big difference from what you had OEM 


http://www.jegs.com/p/Chevrolet-Performance/GM-Goodwrench-350ci-260HP-Engine-Packages/752506/10002/-1 


or complete for 2200.00 
http://www.jegs.com/i/Chevrolet-Performance/809/10067353K1/10002/-1?parentProductId=752506

Look at it this way YOU will have factory NEW and no matter what non-sense a builder talks any builder with an ounce of honesty will admit he can not compete with a crate motor for an average joe who simply needs a motor. If they try to walk away there sales people at that moment. 


______________
1980 , ZZ430 , 3.92 rear , 700R4 2400 stall NEW EZ EFI 
Re: Re-manufactured Engine vs my stock engine (23/23)
 12/17/12 11:42am
nextdoor76
Former Member

Send Private Message

Kimberling City, MO - USA

Vette(s):
1976 Stingray


Joined: 12/2/2012
Posts: 49

Vetto1974 said: Hi I have been contemplating in regards to my engine. I came across with this company in California, west coast engines, www.westcoastengines.com. The remanufactured crate engines. I am looking at 350 ci, 325 hp. The price, $2,499 plus shipping and core of $300. They are using vortec heads. It seems a good price. Is worth buying remanufactured engine? Or, it is better to rebuild my engine? Do you think by rebuilding my engine, will I get to 325 hp? Need help to decide.



My younger brother is really into auto and truck parts, and has been for many years now. I am lucky in the fact that he wanted to rebuild my org. #'s engine. Our thoughts were "while it's apart" and what would be simple upgrades...pistons...camshafts...etc. He feels I should get a good crusin car with 300hp. I have had the trans. rebuild at a race shop...heads at a machine shop that we have used in the past! Trans...was a virgin...and engine got a  very detailed hone work over. Org. had 160,000 miles by 2 other owners and cylinder walls showed almost no wear. So long story...short...get someone you know and trust to help you make your choices!  I have waited 20 years...so just opened the bank account and went for it. LOL

______________
Our Sponsors help support C3VR