Home page
SPONSOR AD

Topic: R-12 Replacement: Freeze-12??

in Forum: C3 Cooling and Heating Systems


R-12 Replacement: Freeze-12??

Posted: 5/25/09 10:44am Message 1 of 11
Lifetime MemberLifetime Member
Send PM
Apache Junction, AZ - USA
Joined: 10/15/2006
Posts: 285
Vette(s): 1982,150K,Renegade CFI,Hooker Side Pipes,85 fuel pump,Bilsteins,HD suspension, Aluminum radiator, SharkBar/w 5-Point Restraints. 3:73 gears coming soon.
I am replacing my compressor in my 82 with OEM which is R12; to fill with R12 the cost will be about $200+
I do not want to retro fit to R134 as it does not cool as good as R12 and I need all the cooling I can get here in AZ for this daily driver.
  Has anyone heard of Freeze12? It is an EPA approved replacement for R12 and does not need a license to purchase. I have heard that Freeze12 it is a butane derivative and that means it is flammable. My common sense is saying NO to flammability. What do you guys think and has anyone used this Freeze12??

  On a side note, I just installed a quality wiring harness with two relays/fuses and 10/12 gauge wiring to go with my aluminum radiator & dual fans. For the last 16 months I had the fans wired to the OEM fan hookups which was not strong enough to handle the amps of these fans. No burnt wires (Luckly) but way less CFM output than correctly rated wires. The fans now blow at 100% efficiency compared to probably 50-70% while wired into the OEM harness.
FYI: Use the correct gauge wiring especially with aftermarket radiator fans, especially dual fans!

Thanks!
Thumbs Up

 



SPONSOR AD:: (Our Sponsors help support C3VR)

R-12 Replacement: Freeze-12??

Posted: 5/25/09 11:56am Message 2 of 11
Profile Pic
Lifetime MemberLifetime Member
Moderator
Send PM
Duncanville, TX - USA
Joined: 11/8/2003
Posts: 20214
Vette(s): #1-1974 L-48 4spd Cp Med Red Metallic/Black deluxe int w/AC/tilt/tele./p/w-p/b/ Am-Fm/map light National/Regional/Chapter NCRS "Top Flight" #2-1985 Bright Red/Carmine Cp.L-98/auto Member: NCRS, NCRS Texas, Corvette Legends of Texas
I would recommend you run away from the Freeze 12...Run, Forest, RUUUN!!
My experience with it has been really bad. On the three vehicles I used it in, all three locked the compressor up within a few days. Whether or not it was the Freeze 12 that did this or not, my statistics lead me to believe it was, as I am certified in automotive HVAC repair, and the rest of the system(s) was properly set up. I even talked to one of their engineers about the product before I ever used it, and the answers to my questions were insane....the guy didn't appear to know anything about the stuff, other than "It is a "drop-in" replacement, no problem"...
I have a few cans of that stuff left in my cabinets, and will not use them.
Perhaps Terry(my7T1) can give more info...
My opinion is the stuff is dangerous.
Adams' Apple2009-05-25 11:57:46


Joel Adams
C3VR Lifetime Member #56    

My Link


(click for Texas-sized view!)
             NCRS

"Money can't buy happiness -- but somehow it's more comforting to cry in a CORVETTE than in a Kia"

R-12 Replacement: Freeze-12??

Posted: 5/25/09 6:46pm Message 3 of 11
Former Member
Send PM
williamston, NC - USA
Joined: 1/19/2006
Posts: 353
Vette(s): 1969 coupe, 350, m22 trans, ac, black on black,
Phill, I am a hvac tech by trade,, I agree with Joel about the freeze 12,,I do not agree with you about 134a,, The performance of 134a is within a few percentage points of r12 when it is properly installed,I do not think you will see an appreciable difference in 134a vs r12,, it is not that big of a deal to convert your ride over to 134a,,good luck,,rd


R-12 Replacement: Freeze-12??

Posted: 5/25/09 7:49pm Message 4 of 11
Profile Pic
Lifetime MemberLifetime Member
Send PM
Dorr, MI - USA
Joined: 8/21/2002
Posts: 2581
Vette(s): 71 Colonnade Hardtop Coupe Torch Red with black interior originally L48 built to push around 360hp

I agree with Joel & Rick. I too am certified HVAC fo 36 years. I have never used any so called drop in refrigerant, and never will. They are all a corktail soup of different refrigerants including R134 & R12. Some R22 and some............yes butane. When the government banned the production of R12, a bunch of company's got on the band wagon to produce a replacement. Most if it, if not all of it is crap as far as I'm concerned. I have used only R134 & R12 in my shop, and like Rick says when retro-fitted properly the little if any difference in duct temp will not be noticed.




R-12 Replacement: Freeze-12??

Posted: 5/25/09 10:06pm Message 5 of 11
Profile Pic
Lifetime MemberLifetime Member
Moderator
Send PM
Burke, VT - USA
Joined: 1/23/2002
Posts: 7282
Vette(s): SOLD - "The Toy" - '70 Convertible
SOLD - "The Beast" - '90 ZR-1 (#682)
SOLD - "Betty" - '28 Ford Model A Tudor
Sold - "BLKBRRD" - '78 Pontiac Trans Am
"BLUBYU" - '04 Coupe
Phil, while I have to believe the comments by the three techs above about R-134 I share your concern about converting to it.  When the condenser in "The Beast" needed to be replaced I did the R-134 conversion because of the current cost of the R-12 and its long term lack of availability.  I have to say I'm less than pleased with its performance.  The C4 does have a lot of glass but then so do the '78-82 C3s.  I have also read that to reduce the horsepower drain the ZR-1 had a slightly smaller capacity compressor so that may be a factor in our case.

I still need to get the A/C brought back to life on "BIGBRRD" but haven't decided yet which non-flammable route to take.  A dark colored car needs all the cooling it can get and I'm not fully convinced yet that R-134 will do the job.



Jim Olson 

"The Toys"...!!!  Save the Wave!

Where I've been in a Corvette...!!!

R-12 Replacement: Freeze-12??

Posted: 5/25/09 10:20pm Message 6 of 11
Profile Pic
Standard Member
Send PM
Grapevine, TX - USA
Joined: 8/26/2006
Posts: 1525
Vette(s): 1972 LT-1 convertible with factory air. 2017 Black Rose Grand Sport convertible.
Check out Enviro Safe   Es12A.  I just replaced all my hoses and am going back with R12.

http://www.es12a.com/
 
 
(made URL link clickable - Norsky)


Norsky2009-05-25 22:31:00


   

R-12 Replacement: Freeze-12??

Posted: 5/26/09 6:48am Message 7 of 11
Profile Pic
Lifetime MemberLifetime Member
Send PM
Dorr, MI - USA
Joined: 8/21/2002
Posts: 2581
Vette(s): 71 Colonnade Hardtop Coupe Torch Red with black interior originally L48 built to push around 360hp
Here is a Composition Chart of alternative refrigerants. If you notice Freeze-12 is 80% R134a. No where can I find composition of ES-12a, other than it does contain Butane.
 
This is what I'm talkin bout when I say so called drop ins (no such thing) are all a bunch-o-crap.
 
Also if charging your system with R134a be sure the label does not say sealer added. Another whole bunch of problems.
 
My .02
 
 
  1. Many refrigerants, including R-401A (made by DuPont), R-401B (DuPont), R-409A (Elf Atochem), Care 30 (Calor Gas), Adak-29/Adak-12 (TACIP Int'l), MT-31 (Millenia Tech), and ES-12R (Intervest), have not been submitted for review in motor vehicle air conditioning, and it is therefore illegal to use these refrigerants in such systems as an alternative to CFC-12.
    1. See text for details on legality of use according to status
    2. Acceptable Subject to Use Conditions
    • regarding fittings, labeling, no drop-in, and compressor shutoff switches.
    • Unacceptable; illegal for use as a CFC-12 substitute in motor vehicle air conditioners




  • R-12 Replacement: Freeze-12??

    Posted: 5/26/09 8:35am Message 8 of 11
    Profile Pic
    Lifetime MemberLifetime Member
    Send PM
    Joined: 7/2/2006
    Posts: 8205
    Stay with R-12 or convert to 134A..........my opinion......let us know how you decide.


    corvette440hp

    R-12 Replacement: Freeze-12??

    Posted: 5/27/09 10:01am Message 9 of 11
    Lifetime MemberLifetime Member
    Send PM
    Apache Junction, AZ - USA
    Joined: 10/15/2006
    Posts: 285
    Vette(s): 1982,150K,Renegade CFI,Hooker Side Pipes,85 fuel pump,Bilsteins,HD suspension, Aluminum radiator, SharkBar/w 5-Point Restraints. 3:73 gears coming soon.
    Thanks for the excellent info guys!!
    It looks like I will stay with the R-12, eBay has 12oz cans for around $30 each.

    How many cans will I need for my AC tech??

    Thanks!
    Thumbs Up



    R-12 Replacement: Freeze-12??

    Posted: 5/27/09 10:47am Message 10 of 11
    Profile Pic
    Lifetime MemberLifetime Member
    Send PM
    Joined: 7/2/2006
    Posts: 8205
    [QUOTE=Phill's Vette]Thanks for the excellent info guys!!
    It looks like I will stay with the R-12, eBay has 12oz cans for around $30 each.

    How many cans will I need for my AC tech??

    Thanks!
    Thumbs Up
    [/QUOTE] 4 120z. cans which equal the 3lb. charge. I would recommend getting one extra to charge or to have in case you need a bit more or for future use. You should really only need the 4, if you want to save the additional $30.00. Good luck and KEEP COOL!  corvette440hp2009-05-27 10:48:12


    corvette440hp

    in Forum: C3 Cooling and Heating Systems


    SPONSOR AD: (Our Sponsors help support C3VR)