Topic: How much "Advance" is too much?
in Forum: C3 Engines
Already a Member?
Click Here to Login
Not yet a Member?
Click Here to Register for Free!
Okay - while we are talking about timing. My engine builder (he builds drag cars) put three marks on my harmonic balancer for timing. He marked the line that is used to set timing and then a ways down is a mark that says 30 and further down is a mark that says 40. What do those mean. The car runs fine but as I read this thread it sounds as though some fine tuning could be done for better performance. Any help or ideas?
SPONSOR AD:: (Our Sponsors help support C3VR)

Moderator
Duncanville, TX - USA
Joined: 11/8/2003
Posts: 20214
Vette(s): #1-1974 L-48 4spd Cp Med Red Metallic/Black deluxe int w/AC/tilt/tele./p/w-p/b/
Am-Fm/map light National/Regional/Chapter NCRS "Top Flight"
#2-1985 Bright Red/Carmine Cp.L-98/auto
Member: NCRS, NCRS Texas, Corvette Legends of Texas
Some builders will mark the balancer to make it easier to set the timing at certain rpms. Most pro racers have the balancer marked all the way around to help with "degree-ing" the cam. Matter of fact, most pro type balancers are marked that way to start with.(Fluidamper, etc.)
For instance, if you wanted 30deg. advance @ 3000rpm, then you would simply set the engine rpm to 3000, and look at the timing mark(30deg), and set that mark(30deg) on the "zero" on the timing tab. I have an advancable timing light, and it does basically the same thing, but it uses electronics to do it. If I want 30deg @ 3000rpm, I just set the rpm, and "dial in" 30deg on the light, and then line up the "0" on the balancer. Does the same thing, with less fuss.
Another trick some engine builders will do, is mark the balancer for true TDC. This involves using a piston stop, and turning the engine by hand until it hits the stop. Mark the balancer there, and then turn the engine the other direction until it hits the stop there, and mark the balancer. The exact center distance between the two marks you just made will be "true" TDC, as seen on the balancer. Then, the balancer is marked at that center distance, to be used as TDC when timing the engine. This eliminates any balancer defects, as far as timing marks go.
Does this make any sense at all?!
For instance, if you wanted 30deg. advance @ 3000rpm, then you would simply set the engine rpm to 3000, and look at the timing mark(30deg), and set that mark(30deg) on the "zero" on the timing tab. I have an advancable timing light, and it does basically the same thing, but it uses electronics to do it. If I want 30deg @ 3000rpm, I just set the rpm, and "dial in" 30deg on the light, and then line up the "0" on the balancer. Does the same thing, with less fuss.
Another trick some engine builders will do, is mark the balancer for true TDC. This involves using a piston stop, and turning the engine by hand until it hits the stop. Mark the balancer there, and then turn the engine the other direction until it hits the stop there, and mark the balancer. The exact center distance between the two marks you just made will be "true" TDC, as seen on the balancer. Then, the balancer is marked at that center distance, to be used as TDC when timing the engine. This eliminates any balancer defects, as far as timing marks go.
Does this make any sense at all?!

Joel Adams
C3VR Lifetime Member #56
My Link
(click for Texas-sized view!) NCRS
"Money can't buy happiness -- but somehow it's more comforting to cry in a CORVETTE than in a Kia"
It does. So I should check my timing at idle, 3000 and 4000 rpm to see if my vac advance is working properly. Should these three marks all hit the same spot when timing at the set RPM?

Moderator
Duncanville, TX - USA
Joined: 11/8/2003
Posts: 20214
Vette(s): #1-1974 L-48 4spd Cp Med Red Metallic/Black deluxe int w/AC/tilt/tele./p/w-p/b/
Am-Fm/map light National/Regional/Chapter NCRS "Top Flight"
#2-1985 Bright Red/Carmine Cp.L-98/auto
Member: NCRS, NCRS Texas, Corvette Legends of Texas
Well, I couldn't tell you WHY he marked the balancer like that. In theory, tho, if you wanted 30deg. advance @ 3000rpm, then the 30deg. mark would line up with the "0" on the timing tab @ 3000rpm. By "0", I mean the TDC position on the timing tab. Most of them are a large "V" shape notch, and are marked as "0".
The total advance, and what RPM it comes in at will vary according to the engine builder's preference, or what actually works best for each engine/vehicle/driver combo. There really is no one set way to do it, or one carved in stone spec. The only real way to get it done properly, for the most usable HP, is on a chassis dyno. Most of us do not have access to one o dem bad boys, so...we just play it by ear!
The total advance, and what RPM it comes in at will vary according to the engine builder's preference, or what actually works best for each engine/vehicle/driver combo. There really is no one set way to do it, or one carved in stone spec. The only real way to get it done properly, for the most usable HP, is on a chassis dyno. Most of us do not have access to one o dem bad boys, so...we just play it by ear!
Joel Adams
C3VR Lifetime Member #56
My Link
(click for Texas-sized view!) NCRS
"Money can't buy happiness -- but somehow it's more comforting to cry in a CORVETTE than in a Kia"

Hot Springs, AR - USA
Joined: 4/24/2004
Posts: 3236
Vette(s): 69 Conv #'s match 427, TKO-600/.64, 3.36HD-Posi, HT, T/T, PS, PB, PW, SP, Leather, Comp XE264HR & Roller Rockers & Lifters, Air-Gap RPM intake, Holley St Av 770 VS, MSD 6AL+Dist+Blaster SS, K&N, Jet-Hot Hooker Side-Pipes, Steeroids, Al Rad, Spal Fans
yes.. a springs change is pretty much a requirement to set the timing perfect..
unfortunately you can the the initial timing high where it will labor on a warm start.
a high torque starter can help this.
but the real issue isnt whether the timing is 13 or 16 at idle..
its the extra 3 degrees at 2500 rpm or wherever your rpms are when youre doggin it.

Hot Springs, AR - USA
Joined: 4/24/2004
Posts: 3236
Vette(s): 69 Conv #'s match 427, TKO-600/.64, 3.36HD-Posi, HT, T/T, PS, PB, PW, SP, Leather, Comp XE264HR & Roller Rockers & Lifters, Air-Gap RPM intake, Holley St Av 770 VS, MSD 6AL+Dist+Blaster SS, K&N, Jet-Hot Hooker Side-Pipes, Steeroids, Al Rad, Spal Fans
[QUOTE=Adams' Apple]Some builders will mark the balancer to make it easier to set the timing at certain rpms. Most pro racers have the balancer marked all the way around to help with "degree-ing" the cam. Matter of fact, most pro type balancers are marked that way to start with.(Fluidamper, etc.)
For instance, if you wanted 30deg. advance @ 3000rpm, then you would simply set the engine rpm to 3000, and look at the timing mark(30deg), and set that mark(30deg) on the "zero" on the timing tab. I have an advancable timing light, and it does basically the same thing, but it uses electronics to do it. If I want 30deg @ 3000rpm, I just set the rpm, and "dial in" 30deg on the light, and then line up the "0" on the balancer. Does the same thing, with less fuss.
Another trick some engine builders will do, is mark the balancer for true TDC. This involves using a piston stop, and turning the engine by hand until it hits the stop. Mark the balancer there, and then turn the engine the other direction until it hits the stop there, and mark the balancer. The exact center distance between the two marks you just made will be "true" TDC, as seen on the balancer. Then, the balancer is marked at that center distance, to be used as TDC when timing the engine. This eliminates any balancer defects, as far as timing marks go.
Does this make any sense at all?!
[/QUOTE]
cthulhu 2006-10-02 12:37:20
For instance, if you wanted 30deg. advance @ 3000rpm, then you would simply set the engine rpm to 3000, and look at the timing mark(30deg), and set that mark(30deg) on the "zero" on the timing tab. I have an advancable timing light, and it does basically the same thing, but it uses electronics to do it. If I want 30deg @ 3000rpm, I just set the rpm, and "dial in" 30deg on the light, and then line up the "0" on the balancer. Does the same thing, with less fuss.
Another trick some engine builders will do, is mark the balancer for true TDC. This involves using a piston stop, and turning the engine by hand until it hits the stop. Mark the balancer there, and then turn the engine the other direction until it hits the stop there, and mark the balancer. The exact center distance between the two marks you just made will be "true" TDC, as seen on the balancer. Then, the balancer is marked at that center distance, to be used as TDC when timing the engine. This eliminates any balancer defects, as far as timing marks go.
Does this make any sense at all?!

you can buy a sticker tape that goes right on the balancer to have the marks.
I just bought a new 8" (instead of stock 7") balancer to go on my 427 and put a tape sticker on there to help in record keeping. (note: you also need to change timing pointer when changing balancer size)
I keep a tuning journal when I do this.. and I generally will map the timing out from idle to peak by 250 rpm..
this gives you a very good mapping of where it is set..
that way when you have your foot to the floor going up a hill and you hear detonation.. just look to see where the tach is.
it is very easy to make a spring change with this info mapped out.

Hot Springs, AR - USA
Joined: 4/24/2004
Posts: 3236
Vette(s): 69 Conv #'s match 427, TKO-600/.64, 3.36HD-Posi, HT, T/T, PS, PB, PW, SP, Leather, Comp XE264HR & Roller Rockers & Lifters, Air-Gap RPM intake, Holley St Av 770 VS, MSD 6AL+Dist+Blaster SS, K&N, Jet-Hot Hooker Side-Pipes, Steeroids, Al Rad, Spal Fans
[QUOTE=jbova2]OK, Her I go again. Can't leave well enough alone and all. LOL
I have advanced the Mallory HEI to Max vacume at idle (1000 RPM)= 16 PSI and took her out for a ride. Ran FANTASTIC,
Would not start at all though, so I backed off the timing to 13 PSI at idle until I could fire her up. Readjusted the carb and all was well until.....
How can I get the full power and the ability to turn the engine over too? I set the timing with a gauge with the vac advance blocked off. Can I alter the vacume advance to kick in around 2500-300 RPM? or am I missing something. Even thought maybe the starter was week (New Starter though) New Battery....Arrrrgggg. I really want it to run like it did at 16 PSI (set at idle) No Pings, No Miss, just F A S T .....Smokin Fast.... At 13 PSI It is not the same......
Thank you for your patience here. I really did look for the other thread and seem to not be able to find it.
Anyone? Ideas?
JB

[/QUOTE]
I have advanced the Mallory HEI to Max vacume at idle (1000 RPM)= 16 PSI and took her out for a ride. Ran FANTASTIC,
Would not start at all though, so I backed off the timing to 13 PSI at idle until I could fire her up. Readjusted the carb and all was well until.....
How can I get the full power and the ability to turn the engine over too? I set the timing with a gauge with the vac advance blocked off. Can I alter the vacume advance to kick in around 2500-300 RPM? or am I missing something. Even thought maybe the starter was week (New Starter though) New Battery....Arrrrgggg. I really want it to run like it did at 16 PSI (set at idle) No Pings, No Miss, just F A S T .....Smokin Fast.... At 13 PSI It is not the same......
Thank you for your patience here. I really did look for the other thread and seem to not be able to find it.
Anyone? Ideas?
JB

[/QUOTE]
take your springs down 1 setting.. OR it may be that your limit is too low.
if you have a limit bushing.. make it one size smaller
try one at a time.. but try both as well..
Reading all the posts on the subject of timing the engine, I'm really confused now.
I have Edelbrock heads, factory aluminum intake manifold, and HEI distributor off late-model small block without vacuum advance canister.
Car runs terrific, but when stopped at traffic light for instance, when the idle drops way down, (automatic transmission by the way), it runs like crap. Just about stays running, usually have to put it into neutral until the light changes, then nurse it along to keep it running until it gets off idle.
I'm still running the Q-Jet and have tried to find any vacuum leaks that might be causing the stumbles, but it seems like that is not the problem.
Is it possible that my brake booster has gone bad, and when I'm stepping on the brake, I'm creating a vacuum leak in the booster can?
I've played with timing and it's now set at 14 degrees, which I set with timing light.
Jim
Good Morning, First I want to thank you and everyone who has contributed to this thread.
Finally got to changing out the springs after verifying that max advance was not happening untill well over 4000 RPM. So, when I pulled the rotor I discovered springs the size of GM's largest front coil springs LOL Really big and stiff compared to the Mr. Gasket Spring kit's Gold/Silver/Black ie; heaviest to lightest respectively. We tried the Black, then Silver and back to Black (Lightest) for a result of 8 degrees initial (Engine starts without effort) and total advance is kicking in low at around 2000 RPM (34-36 deg)
Idle is smooth at 750-800 RPM. We are getting really really close to getting it right. I had it fall on it's face one time and thats enough to let me know that we may have to raise the idle in drive to around 900-1000? and perhaps even boot the initial up to around 10-12 deg.
Again Thanks for all of the help and By the Way if anyone needs a set of used coil springs...
LOL

JB
in Forum: C3 Engines
SPONSOR AD: (Our Sponsors help support C3VR)